REIT stock prices are trading at levels well below net asset value. That makes buybacks more appealing. Bank of America REIT analyst Jana Galan said the REITs are trading at an implied cap rate around 6%. Meanwhile, we’re seeing REIT-quality apartments selling for cap rates ranging from mid-4s to low 5s. That’s a sizable gap that makes buybacks more attractive.
From multifamily REIT earnings calls last week:
EQR’s Mark Parrell said: “The best capital allocation opportunity we see now is to sell properties that we see as having lower forward return profiles and using the sales proceeds to buy back our stock. As you saw in the release, the company purchased approximately $206 million of its stock during the fourth quarter and just subsequent to quarter end for total stock purchases of $300 million in 2025. We see our company with its high-quality asset base and sophisticated operating platform as greatly undervalued in the public markets versus private market values. Also, by acquiring stock with the proceeds from the sales of slower growth properties, we’re effectively improving our forward growth rate as well, a double benefit.”
UDR’s Dave Bragg: “The magnitude of discount to NAV that has persisted in the space just doesn’t happen very often, and we are fortunate that we’ve taken advantage of it so far and plan to continue to do so as we execute on dispositions.”
Camden’s Ric Campo: Once Camden sells its SoCal portfolio, “We also look at the opportunity to redeploy the capital not only in the Sun Belt, but also to buy the shares. And so when we can sell the California portfolio at a cap rate that’s substantially less than our implied cap rate implied in our stock.”
IRT’s Jim Sebra: “Like a lot of our peers, there is a fundamental disconnect between implied cap rates as well as market cap rates. And we looked at that as a good opportunity … to buy back stock.”
Source: Jay Parsons
Multifamily Market News 